Mental Health

The Two Types of Decision Makers and How They Think

By Dynne C. | Update Date: Jan 12, 2024 03:15 AM EST

Decision-making is a complex cognitive process that shapes our daily lives. From choosing what to wear in the morning to making career-altering choices, individuals make several decisions they don't even recognize. 

Decisions can be challenging, especially when faced with multiple options. There are many reasons why it becomes a difficult process, especially in situations where one decision can affect other people and events, like that of managers and business owners.

Experts have looked into the challenges individuals encounter during this process. Anxiety, fear of making the wrong choice, and the overwhelming abundance of possibilities can paralyze decision-makers. To explore these difficulties, researchers often categorize decision-makers into two main groups: maximizers and satisficers

Maximizers who prioritize perfection

Maximizers are individuals who seek the best possible outcome. They meticulously evaluate all available options, exhaustively comparing features and weighing potential outcomes. This exhaustive approach can lead to decision fatigue, stress and even dissatisfaction. Maximizers often aim for perfection, striving to make optimal choices, but this pursuit can come at the cost of time and mental well-being.

Maximizers tend to have higher expectations and experience more regret over their decisions. The brain's prefrontal cortex, responsible for decision-making, is often overstimulated in maximizers, contributing to the stress associated with their approach.

Satisficers and their quest for a satisfactory solution

On the other end of the spectrum are satisficers, individuals who seek a satisfactory solution rather than an optimal one. Satisficers set clear criteria for decision-making, and once those criteria are met, they make their choice without exhaustive comparison. This approach can be more efficient and less mentally taxing than the maximizer's method.

Satisficers exhibit lower levels of decision-related stress. Their brains are less burdened during the decision-making process, allowing for quicker and more decisive choices. Studies have shown that satisficers often report higher levels of life satisfaction, as they prioritize the practicality and attainability of their decisions over the pursuit of perfection.

© 2023 Counsel & Heal All rights reserved. Do not reproduce without permission.

Join the Conversation

Real Time Analytics